Generator or battery? Your state's outage record decides it
The average American household lost 11 hours of electricity in 2024. Take the storm days out and the same year is 2.2 hours. That gap is the entire argument: a battery covers the ordinary year quietly and indoors, a generator exists for the tail, and in an apartment the tail is somebody else's problem because you cannot legally run one. Pick your state below and the decision stops being a matter of opinion.
No affiliate links and no product recommendation on this page. It is a free tool and a field note: the numbers and the rule are here, the shopping is yours.
What your state loses, and what your house needs
The left half of this is federal record: how many hours your state's customers lost in 2024, how often, and how long one interruption ran. The right half is arithmetic on your own house. Pick what you would keep alive and the tool tells you the watt-hours, which is the only number that matters when you compare a battery to a battery.
When each machine is the right machine
A battery, almost always, first. It works indoors, it makes no exhaust and no noise, it needs no fuel that goes stale, and it covers the outage the average household actually gets. It is also the only one of the two that an apartment can own: Ready.gov's rule is that a generator runs outdoors and at least twenty feet from windows, doors and attached garages, and no balcony in the country meets that.
A generator, when the tail is long and you have the ground for it. If your state's number with storms included is many times its number without them, you do not have an electricity problem, you have a hurricane problem, and the events that matter run for days rather than hours. No battery you can carry covers three days of a fridge. Fuel, a place to run it far from the house, and a carbon monoxide detector on every level are the price of entry.
Neither, for heat. Look at what the space heater does to the numbers above. Electric heat is the one job where a battery is hopeless and a small generator is barely better. Warmth in an outage comes from layers, one closed room, and leaving the building if it gets dangerous.
The three lines are our judgement. The hours, the frequencies and the twenty feet are not; they carry their sources above.
Hours without power in 2024, worst to best
Two numbers per state, because the difference between them is the story. The first includes the major storm days; the second is the same year with those days taken out, which is roughly what a normal year feels like. The last column is the share of that state's customers the report actually covers, and where it is low the number above it is a hint rather than a measurement.
| State | Hours lost, all events | Storms removed | Outages a year | Customers covered |
|---|
Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration, Electric Power Annual, Table 11.2 (IEEE method), data for 2024, released 16 Oct 2025; read 11 Sept 2026. Minutes converted to hours. A state average covers a whole grid: a rural line at the end of a long feeder and a downtown block on buried cable live in different worlds inside the same number.
A cheap generator against an expensive battery, measured
We own neither machine, so we have no test to show you. The most useful comparison we found is by The Solar Lab, who runs a two hundred dollar petrol generator against a two thousand dollar power station and counts what each actually delivers. It is their work, shown here with their embed enabled; the credit and the link go to them.
Get the next chapter in your inbox
One email a week, the new chapter and the tool that goes with it. No sales pitches, unsubscribe in one click.
You'll get a confirmation email first. We don't sell or share your address.
- i.How much water your house needs, and the Water Freedom System review
- ii.Rain barrel calculator, by state
- iii.48 hours without power: a small apartment's quiet plan
- iv.A 30-day pantry, priced with this month's numbers
- v.Generator vs. battery: what your state's outages say
- vi.Water from air, explained by the humidity where you live
- vii.This week's drought map, and your plan on top of it
- viii.Filter, treat, test: making stored water drinkable
- ix.The blackout kit you already own
Questions people ask
How long does the power actually stay off?
Battery or generator?
Why can a battery not run my heater?
How accurate are these state numbers?
What about a whole-house standby generator?
Last updated: 11 September 2026. Outage figures are federal data for 2024 with the source shown; wattages are our estimates and yours will differ.
How we stay honest: this page has no affiliate links, no sponsor and no product recommendation. The outage figures are public federal data with the release date and the date we read them. The wattages are our own starting estimates and say so; the rule for choosing is our judgement and says so. The safety rule about running a generator outdoors comes from Ready.gov and is not ours to soften. The video belongs to the creator credited above, and nothing here is electrical or safety engineering advice for your specific home.